"The cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy (composition)? The problem of genre

Date:

2018-03-23 04:13:14

Views:

526

Rating:

1Like 0Dislike

Share:

Table of contents:

The Latest Comedy play by A. P. Chekhov became “the Cherry orchard». After the play ‘Three sisters" of the somewhat tragic works, Chekhov suddenly thought about a new one. And somehow he wanted to, and even wrote about it to his friends, this time, she was very funny, at least in concept. To answer the question, “the Cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy, it is worth noting that the author himself has defined it for the second genre. However, during the life of Chekhov, when was the first production at the Moscow art theatre, the play was presented as serious drama and even tragedy.

the cherry orchard drama or Comedy

“the Cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy? Essay

Then where is the truth? Drama by definition is a literary work that is designed primarily for life on the stage. At the stage it attains its full existence, reveals its meaning, which further defines its genre. But the last word in the definition of the genre, whatever it was, it was always with the theatre, Directors and actors. A well-known fact that the innovative ideas of Chekhov as a playwright theatres understood and perceived reluctantly, and not immediately, but slowly and with great difficulty. If you write about «the Cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy, an essay on this subject can be based on Mat the traditional interpretation that this is a dramatic Elegy-definition, which was fixed to play at the authorities of theatrical art, such as Stanislavsky and Nemirovich-Danchenko. The Czechs about it then still managed to make the theatre their outrage this interpretation.

Recommended

LP - a woman or a man, and is it important?

LP - a woman or a man, and is it important?

Those who have ever bothered to become acquainted with the works of the magic of the singer LP, was irrevocably in love with her amazing charisma, emancipation and fascinating game now popular on the ukulele tool. Her real fans have stopped to wonder...

The Song

The Song "Gibraltar-Labrador". Meanings and images

The Song "Gibraltar-Labrador" Vyacheslav Butusov became known to the General public in 1997. She became part of the sound track of the famous film by Alexei Balabanov, "Brother 2". Today it listens to the second generation of fans of Russian rock. In...

Ewan McGregor: filmography, biography actor

Ewan McGregor: filmography, biography actor

Audiences love films with participation of actors of the ordinary. So in the eyes of many was Ewan McGregor. His filmography includes more than sixty works, with diverse and multifaceted. Evan with equal success, delves into the images of rich and po...

the problem of the genre of the cherry orchard drama or Comedy

“the Cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy? Briefly about everything

The plot plays former owners said goodbye to their family nest. In the second half of the nineteenth century, even before Chekhov, this topic is often covered in the Russian literature, and dramatic, and tragic, and comic. Try to understand what are the peculiarities of this problem, and how to perceive “the Cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy.

This attitude of Chekhov was determined by the fact that instead of the nobility, gradually sivumela yourself and outgoing in social oblivion, was to replace capitalism, and is very pronounced in the images of the now-impoverished noblewoman and Lopakhin – a wealthy man, and the grandson of a former serf. In these two classes the Czechs saw the successors of national culture. In the noble class writer has seen, first and foremost, the focus of Russian culture. Here, of course, do not forget about serfdom referred to in the play, but still in first place culture.

Chekhov the cherry orchard a drama or Comedy

Ranevskaya and Lopakhin

One of the main characters - Ranevskaya, she's the lady of the house and his soul. And so, despite all its flaws and silliness (and they emphasize that in Paris she became an addict) when he returned Home to his father's house, everything around was transformed and revived. The house stretched seemingly forever left its inhabitants.

Another key protagonist is Lopakhin, which just exactly matched it. He also loves poetry, he has a soft and delicate fingers, like the artist, sensitive and vulnerable soul. In the foyer he feels strongly native soul. However, the vulgarity of life on all sides began to advance on him, and he acquires some features of the uhar-merchant, which focuses on its democratic origins, and even flaunts a lack of culture that was then the norm in the prestigious “advanced circles”. But he also expects Ranevskaya to near it somehow to be cleared and try again to resume your artistic and poetic interests and preferences. To thoroughly deal with the question of «the Cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy, you have to go to a deeper analysis of the work.

the cherry orchard a drama or Comedy briefly

Patronage

So, is the vision of the capitalists Chekhov is indeed based on real facts. Then a wealthy the end of the century there has been enormous interest, concern and love for the culture. This can be seen on the example of such big capitalists-philanthropists as Mammoths, Denis Morozov that contained the entire theater. Or take the Tretyakov brothers, who founded the capital's famous art gallery, or merchant's son Alekseeva, which is more than all of us known under the name of Stanislavsky. By the way, he brought not only a huge creative potential in the theatre, but all his father's wealth, which was considerable.

the cherry orchard a drama or Comedy writing

But if to speak about the Actor, he is a capitalist of a different order, and that is why he failed in the relationship with Varya. After all, they are not a couple, she is slim, poetic soul, he is already a wealthy merchant, mundane and everyday nature. For him, the Cooking, the adopted daughter of Ranevskaya, has become, alas, the prose of life.

Chekhov

Considering the deeper theme “the Problem of genre. «the Cherry orchard»: drama or Comedy”, it should be noted that Anton Pavlovich was reflected in her many life experiences and vision. This selling of native lands in Taganrog, and familiarity with Kiselyov, who becamethe prototype of the hero Gaeva, in his estate of babkino family Chekhov for two consecutive years, from 1885 to 1887, rested in the summer, it was sold for debt.

Chekov was a guest in Kharkov province in the estate Lintvarevy he saw a lot of running and ravaged the estates of the nobility, it gave him the plot of the play. In it he wanted to show some of the details of the life of the former inhabitants of the old aristocratic land.

“the Cherry orchard». Reviews

The Work «the Cherry orchard" was given a very difficult, sick Chekhov wrote to friends that works with unbearable torment and writes four lines a day. About the play «the Cherry orchard» he will also write M. P. Alekseeva, that he came out not a drama, a Comedy, in places even a farce. Knipper will note that the play is quite funny and frivolous. But Stanislavsky took her to the drama of Russian life, he wrote: “This is not a Comedy, it is a tragedy… I cried like a woman”.

the cherry orchard a tragedy or drama Comedy writing

And now, back to the question, “the Cherry orchard" - drama, Comedy or tragedy, I must say that Chekhov held the premiere of the play on the day of his birth, January 17, 1904, it seemed that the theatre is not in a tone that's not the tearful drama and role Lopukhin and Vari even have to be comic. But Stanislavsky and Nemirovich-Danchenko, assessing very highly, the play still took it more as a drama. Were critics who considered it a tragicomedy. But A. I. Revyakin in his review writes that if we accept the play, the drama, it is necessary to recognize the experiences of all owners Ranevsky and Gaevich truly dramatic, evoking compassion and deep sympathy to those people who looked not to the past and into the future. But this is not and cannot be. Therefore the play cannot be taken as a tragicomedy, because it lacks any tragicomic situations or characters.

Arguments

The debate about the genre of “the Cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy, still do not cease. Moreover, the range has expanded to circle lyric Comedy or tragicomedy. Therefore unequivocally to answer a question that involuntary way created a Chekhov: “the Cherry orchard" - drama or Comedy?”, is practically impossible.

And once again, referring to the letters that he wrote the great classic of Russian literature and playwright Anton Chekhov, we find the following lines, which describe his true attitude to life, which States that after the summer will be winter, after youth comes old age, happiness and unhappiness, too, periodically, and will replace each other, and the man can't be always healthy and happy, because as always it will wait for the failures, the losses, and to protect themselves from death he will never, even if he is himself a Macedonian. In life, no matter how it looked sad and upset, you need to be prepared and to relate to current events, as inevitable and necessary. «it is Necessary only to do their duty – and nothing more”. In the novel «the Cherry orchard" all these thoughts are consonant with the feelings it causes.

the cherry orchard drama or Comedy

Conclusion

Chekhov argues that fiction is so named because that describes life for what it is. And it has its purpose – to bring the truth of unconditional and honest. It is possible to finish the discussion about “the Cherry orchard» – tragedy, drama or Comedy. An essay on this topic everyone can write their own, because it is quite extensive and requires consideration of different points of view.


Article in other languages:

BE: https://www.tostpost.com/be/mastactva-zabavy/12294-v-shnevy-sad---drama-c-kamedyya-sachynenne-prablema-zhanru.html

DE: https://www.tostpost.com/de/kunst-und-unterhaltung/12296-der-kirschgarten---drama-oder-kom-die-komposition-das-problem-des-genr.html

ES: https://www.tostpost.com/es/arte-y-entretenimiento/12304-el-jard-n-de-los-cerezos---el-drama-o-la-comedia-composici-n-el-proble.html

KK: https://www.tostpost.com/kk/ner-zh-ne-oyyn-sauy/12297-vishnevyy-sad---drama-nemese-komediya-shy-arma-problemasy-zhanr.html

PL: https://www.tostpost.com/pl/sztuka-i-rozrywka/12290-wi-niowy-sad---dramat-czy-komedia-wypracowanie-problem-gatunku.html

PT: https://www.tostpost.com/pt/artes-e-entretenimento/12284-um-pomar-de-cerejas---drama-ou-com-dia-composi-o-o-problema-do-g-nero.html

TR: https://www.tostpost.com/tr/sanat-ve-e-lence/12299-vi-ne-bah-esi---drama-veya-komedi-kompozisyon-sorun-tarz.html

UK: https://www.tostpost.com/uk/mistectvo-ta-rozvagi/12297-vishneviy-sad---drama-chi-komed-ya-tv-r-problema-zhanru.html






Alin Trodden - author of the article, editor
"Hi, I'm Alin Trodden. I write texts, read books, and look for impressions. And I'm not bad at telling you about it. I am always happy to participate in interesting projects."

Comments (0)

This article has no comment, be the first!

Add comment

Related News

Opera

Opera "Alcina", the Bolshoi theatre: reviews, description, history and interesting facts

To the sensation of the theatrical season of 2017 include the Opera "Alcina" by Handel at the New stage of the Bolshoi theatre. Director Katie Mitchell with his production gives the opportunity to reconsider the traditional relati...

Musician Alexander Sklyar: biography, family and creativity

Musician Alexander Sklyar: biography, family and creativity

Alexander Sklar – a talented musician, founder of the group “broke”. You know his biography? Or marital status? Want to know what the path to glory he did? Then we recommend you to read the article from beginning...

Pseudo-Russian style, its characteristic features and peculiarities of development

Pseudo-Russian style, its characteristic features and peculiarities of development

Pseudo-Russian style is an architectural trend in Russia in the 19-20 centuries. The predominant elements here are the traditions of architecture and folk art. It includes several subgroups, including the Russian-Byzantine and neo...

How to draw a family? A Handbook for parents and children

How to draw a family? A Handbook for parents and children

Family for each person — perhaps the most important thing in life. Ideas about home, family tree, ancestors are cultivated in different countries and almost all of the peoples of the Earth! They are built into us at the gene...

The most successful movies

The most successful movies

Everyone loves to watch movies. Every man likes your genre: some like fighters, some like fantasy or horror, and someone Comedy. All these genres are United by the actors and the idea. At different times, were the films of differe...

The film

The film "Status of brad": reviews, cast, plot

more recently, in the film appeared in the controversial movie "the Status of brad". Once a man understands that life is not lived as it should have been. But the ambiguity lies in the fact that he basically has everything that ma...